Community Review

Balmenach 15 Year Old, Batch No. 5, That Boutique-y Whisky Company, 50.1%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

87 / 100

The malty opening has real presence, while summer berry tart and a subtle Bakewell tart note keep the sweetness interesting rather than one-note. On the palate, immediate spice runs alongside tropical fruit juice and seaside fudge, before juicy pears and cream soften the edges. That shift appeals to me: the cinnamon and nutmeg have a point to make, but they don't get the entire agenda. Butteriness carries into a whisper of chocolate ice cream, then a long, dry finish provides a useful counterweight. There's enough change from start to finish to hold my interest, without the sweeter notes taking over. I'd favour that movement over a simpler, uniformly sweet whisky.

Reviewed by CinnamonCloud

Nose
powerfully malty, summer berry tart, liquorice sweeties, subtle Bakewell tart
Palate
immediate spice, tropical fruit juice, seaside fudge, buttery shortbread, cinnamon and nutmeg, juicy pears and cream
Finish
continued buttery richness, a whisper of chocolate ice cream, long, dry finish

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.