Taste. Review. Remember.

Whisky Reviews /My Whisky Diary

Empowering the whisky world with shared whisky journeys.

Discover tasting notes, ratings and your personal Whisky Diary in one polished community workspace.

Total Reviews0
Whiskies Reviewed0
Reviewers0

Community Rating Overview

Tap to view whiskies in this rating range

Sign in to publish your tasting notes from the full composer.Write a Review

All reviews

Community Reviews

From the Maltiply community

Community Reviews

Arran Single Cask 15 Year Old, Bourbon Cask, Cask #1410, 2011, 55.4%
#1Australia
Arran Single Cask 15 Year Old, Bourbon Cask, Cask #1410, 2011, 55.4%
87/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The Bourbon cask is a clear point of interest; the notes bring dark fruit, vanilla and caramel, then finish with spicy, dry oak. A lively little contrast.

Nose: Rich, juicy dark fruits, Vanilla, Honey, Caramel, Banana, Coconut, Soft oakinessPalate: Fruity maltiness, Smooth and buttery, Cinnamon, Caramel, Chocolate, Hints of coffee and nutsFinish: Spicy, Lingering, Very smooth, Dark fruits, Dry, spicy oak
Rich, juicy dark fruitsVanillaHoneyCaramel
Redbreast Oloroso Sherry 21 Year Old, Cask #21285, 2000, 58.7%
#3United States
Redbreast Oloroso Sherry 21 Year Old, Cask #21285, 2000, 58.7%
89/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The appeal here is the contrast between rich fruit and dark chocolate, with spice, leather and tobacco adding a more savoury edge. The richly sherried palate and long, tobacco-led finish make this read as a mature, layered style rather than a straightforward fruit-forward one. At 21 years old and 58.7% ABV, it has plenty of stated heft, though the notes do not describe how that strength comes across. The SGD 1,006.05 sale-price reference puts it at a substantial price point, so the distinctive sherry-and-tobacco character is central to its appeal.

Nose: Rich fruits, Dark chocolate, Spices, Leather, TobaccoPalate: Mature, Complex, Richly sherriedFinish: Long, Spicy, Fruity, Tobacco-led
Rich fruitsDark chocolateSpicesLeather
Heaven's Door Redbreast Master Blenders' Edition 10 Year Old, New Charred Oak & Redbreast Irish Whiskey Cask, 50%
#5South Africa
Heaven's Door Redbreast Master Blenders' Edition 10 Year Old, New Charred Oak & Redbreast Irish Whiskey Cask, 50%
87/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The honeycomb and butterscotch sound like a friendly opening, and the walnut with chocolate peanut gives it a nuttier turn. Plum carries through to the finish, with caramel and peppercorn keeping things lively.

Nose: Honeycomb and butterscotch, Hints of plum, Campino sweets, almonds, and cherriesPalate: Walnut and chocolate peanut, Raisin, cinnamon, butterscotch, orange peel, and vanillaFinish: Caramel, peppercorn, and plum
Honeycomb and butterscotchHints of plum, Campino sweets, almonds, and cherriesWalnut and chocolate peanutRaisin, cinnamon, butterscotch, orange peel, and vanilla
Balblair 2003 1st Release 10 Year Old, Second Fill Bourbon Cask, 2013, 46%
#7Indonesia
Balblair 2003 1st Release 10 Year Old, Second Fill Bourbon Cask, 2013, 46%
86/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The bright citrus and floral notes keep this from feeling heavy, while honey and spice add a warmer edge. The fairly spicy finish sounds more forward than my usual preference, though the fruit gives it a welcome counterpoint.

Nose: Bright floral notes and delicate lemon and orange blossom, Apricots, honey, vanilla, malt and applesPalate: Oranges and lemons with honey and spice, Vanilla, malt, white wine acidity, pepper, fresh mint and caramelFinish: Fairly spicy and long-lasting, with ginger, pepper and oranges
Bright floral notes and delicate lemon and orange blossomApricots, honey, vanilla, malt and applesOranges and lemons with honey and spiceVanilla, malt, white wine acidity, pepper, fresh mint and caramel
Glen Grant 21 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 2022, 46%
#8Singapore
Glen Grant 21 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 2022, 46%
90/100Amazing!Definite Buy

The appeal is the contrast between ripe, bright fruit and the richer caramel and creamy notes. Cinnamon and nutmeg give that sweetness a gentle warmth, while dried fruit and toasted almond carry through to a long finish. It sounds generous without relying on a single dominant note. For a quiet preference for balance, that interplay makes this a particularly inviting direction.

Nose: Ripe peaches, toffee, raisins, tropical fruits, orange, honey, and cinnamon sugar.Palate: Rich tropical fruits, creamy butter, apricot, pineapple, caramel, vanilla, cinnamon, and nutmeg.Finish: Long and enduring, with caramelized crème brûlée, toasted almond, gentle spice, and dried fruit.
Ripe peaches, toffee, raisins, tropical fruits, orange, honey, and cinnamon sugar.Rich tropical fruits, creamy butter, apricot, pineapple, caramel, vanilla, cinnamon, and nutmeg.Long and enduring, with caramelized crème brûlée, toasted almond, gentle spice, and dried fruit.
Glenfarclas 25 Years Highland Single Malt 25 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry Cask, 43%
#9United Kingdom
Glenfarclas 25 Years Highland Single Malt 25 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry Cask, 43%
88/100Excellent!Strong Buy

This 25-year-old Scottish single malt brings sherry, dark fruit and chocolate together in a warm, inviting way. The long, oak-rich finish adds a drier edge, giving it plenty of character.

Nose: Menthol, sherry, citrus, marzipan, dark fruits and chocolatePalate: Sherry, creamy barley, gingerbread, treacle, raisins and maraschino cherriesFinish: Oak, smoke, cocoa, sherried spice and baking spices
Menthol, sherry, citrus, marzipan, dark fruits and chocolateSherry, creamy barley, gingerbread, treacle, raisins and maraschino cherriesOak, smoke, cocoa, sherried spice and baking spices
Karuizawa 17 Year Old 100% Malt, Sherry Cask, 40%
#10Italy
Karuizawa 17 Year Old 100% Malt, Sherry Cask, 40%
87/100Excellent!Strong Buy

There’s a pleasing tension between the fruit and sweetness and the more assertive spice. Dried plum and fig on the nose lead into delicate orchard fruit, honey and almond on the palate; the finish brings black pepper, chili and peat alongside dried-fruit sweetness. That contrast is the part I find most compelling. The palate’s gentle touch of spice sounds quieter than the peppery, peaty finish, so this reads as layered rather than simply sweet.

Nose: Dried plum, fig and black cherry, Almond paste and vanilla-toffee, Cedar, leather and subtle smoke, Clove and nutmegPalate: Delicate orchard fruit, honey and subtle oak, Citrus zest and almond, Hints of peat smoke, peanuts and baked appleFinish: Warm oak, vanilla and dried-fruit sweetness, Nutmeg, clove, cocoa and cedar, Black pepper, peat, oil and chili
Dried plum, fig and black cherryAlmond paste and vanilla-toffeeCedar, leather and subtle smokeClove and nutmeg
Showing 1 to 10 of 100 reviews
...
Real PeopleVerified community reviews
Honest OpinionsNo paid or sponsored reviews
Tasting InsightsTaste, notes and experience
Global CommunityFrom the Maltiply community
Share your experienceWrite a review and help others discover great whiskies.Write a Review