Community Review

Buffalo Trace Eagle Rare 17 Year Old, New Charred Oak Cask, 2023, 50.5%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

There’s an appealing contrast here between rich caramel and dried fruit and the pronounced oak, with chocolate adding another darker note. The finish is described as long, dry and spicy, with earthy cigar-box character. That oak presence gives this bourbon a more structured feel than a purely sweet profile, while the fruit and vanilla keep it inviting. The unpeated label doesn’t need to carry the flavour story; the documented notes make the oak and spice the more interesting thread.

Reviewed by bluehour_notebook

Nose
Caramel, Toasted oak, Dried fruit, Vanilla, Warm spice, Dark chocolate, Cherry pie
Palate
Rich caramel, Dried fruit, Vanilla, Chocolate, Pronounced oak
Finish
Long, Refined, Dry, Spicy, Earthy, Cigar-box notes

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.