Community Review

Caol Ila The Suspects Chess Investigation Series 9 Year Old, Sherry Cask, 2007, Signatory Vintage, 60%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

There’s a clear push and pull here: red fruits, raisins and dark chocolate bring dense sherry sweetness, while peat, ash and liquorice keep the palate firmly smoky. The finish’s pepper, lemon and chalky note give that weight a brighter edge, which is the detail I find most appealing. The floral character on the nose adds another lift. It sounds bold and concentrated rather than delicate, but the contrast is specific enough to make this an engaging fit for someone drawn to clearly defined, layered whisky.

Reviewed by saltair owl

Nose
Smoky, Flowery, Peppery, Red fruits, Raisins, Dark chocolate
Palate
Red fruits, Raisins, Dark chocolate, Peaty, Ashy, Liquorice, Sweetness of sherry, Strength of peat
Finish
Long, Spicy, Pepper, Lemon, Chalky note, Smoky, Salty, Moderate tarry notes

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.