Community Review

Coleburn Connoisseurs Choice 23 Year Old, 1972, Gordon & MacPhail, 40%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

The appeal here is the balance between a light, floral nose with orchard fruit and soft honey, then a more cereal-forward palate with mellow wood spice. That shift gives the whisky a clear center without making the character feel busy. The gentle oak spice and refined finish suit a preference for measured, polished malt rather than a forceful or heavily spiced style.

Reviewed by TidepoolRover

Nose
Light, floral, orchard fruit, soft honey
Palate
Rounded, cereal-forward, mellow wood spice, subtle depth
Finish
Gentle oak spice, refined

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.