Community Review

Highland Park Connoisseurs Choice 35 Year Old, Refill Bourbon Barrel Cask, Cask #2140933, Batch No. 23/019, 1987, Gordon & MacPhail, 56.9%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

The appeal is the balance between honeyed sweetness and soft smoke: citrus and orchard fruit keep the nose lively, while gentle peat and oak give the palate a more grounded edge. That contrast feels especially well judged in the notes, with ripe pear and toffee adding sweetness without crowding out the spice. A long finish carrying honey, smoke, citrus and delicate oak rounds it out. This is a thoughtful, layered character rather than a single-note dram, and the descriptions support a warm, positive view.

Reviewed by TidepoolRover

Nose
Honey, citrus zest, heather, soft smoke, vanilla, orchard fruits, light oak.
Palate
Ripe pear, toffee, malt sweetness, gentle peat smoke, subtle spice, refined oak.
Finish
Lingering honeyed sweetness, soft smoke, citrus, delicate oak.

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.