Community Review

Macallan Classic Cut 2017 Edition, Oloroso Sherry Cask, 2017, 58.4%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

89 / 100

The oak looks well placed here: it carries through the palate and finish, but sits alongside sherry, dried fruit and sweet spice rather than taking over. That relationship makes the description feel coherent, especially with vanilla and caramel softening the oak spices. The finish’s gradual drying adds a useful counterpoint to the syrupy palate. This is the sort of oak-led balance I find appealing, with enough fruit and ginger to keep the wood from becoming the whole story.

Reviewed by busstop.fox

Nose
Strong, wet sherry cask, Sweet ginger, oak, vanilla, sugar cane, Red fruits, baked dates, orange, peach, A hint of freshly ground pepper
Palate
Thick and syrupy, Caramel, oak spices, sherry, dried fruits, vanilla, Ginger, malt, cinnamon
Finish
Lingering nutmeg, cinnamon, almonds, ginger, oak, sweet caramel, Drying as it diminishes

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.