Community Review

Speyside The Trojan 25 Year Old, Refill Hogshead Cask, Cask #410, 1990, Exile, 57.3%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

89 / 100

The oak seems to sit comfortably with the fruit rather than crowding it out: polished wood and spice meet yellow plums, apples and honey on the nose, then aromatic oak joins apricot and citrus on the palate. The slightly drier finish gives the wood a clearer voice, with oak spice alongside raisins and chocolate. That balance makes the documented oak feel like a useful thread through the whisky, not a separate layer imposed on it. It sounds warmly rounded, with enough fruit to keep the wood from becoming the whole story.

Reviewed by silver.postcard

Nose
Yellow plums, baked red apples, honey and polished wood, Hay, subtle wax and spice
Palate
Apricots, citrus and gooseberries with honeyed notes, Aromatic oak, pepper, liquorice and chocolate
Finish
Long and slightly drier, with brioche, raisins and oak spices, Milk chocolate, dark chocolate, honey and wood

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.