Community Review

Brora Rare Old 35 Year Old, First Fill Sherry Cask, Lot No. RO/13/05, 1978, Gordon & MacPhail, 46%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

95 / 100

This 1978 vintage from Gordon & MacPhail is a serious piece for any high-end collection. With Brora being a closed distillery, the scarcity alone drives the floor price, and this Rare Old bottling holds its own against official releases. The first-fill sherry influence is controlled, allowing that classic waxiness to show. It is a bottle worth chasing before the supply dries up further.

Reviewed by Tony Money

Nose
Waxy textures with dense rhubarb jam, soft peat smoke and peppermint, hints of engine oil and dried hay
Palate
Polished oak and rose petal notes, heavy wax and honey core, smoked meat and rare fruit like plum
Finish
Long finish with milk chocolate, lingering salt and bacon, subtle minty smoke

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.